Who is Holden Caulfield? The narrator of The Catcher in the Rye has become one of the most infamous characters in American literature. Some view him as a symbol of the angst and emotions that teenagers experience. Others believe he is a spoiled brat. So who is Holden, a figure of adolescent tribulations, or a self-absorded droppout?
In several ways, Holden posseses the viewpoint of someone much older and more experienced than he is. He believes that there is almost no kindness in people. He can easily identify people's alterior motives, often calling them "phonies." He also seems to not want to have strong personal ties to anyone, not even his own family. He feels he can't rely on anyone but himself. This outlook on life is shared by many individuals who are Holden's age.
As mature as his persepective might make him seem, Holden is actually quite immature. When we meet him, he is flunking out of a school for the third time. This is not because he is not intellegent, but because he doesn't give any effort. Many teens have emotional issues, but it is not a good excuse to fail school. Holden is also a self-proclaimed compulsive liar. His belief that no one is genuine could simply be a reflection of his own personality and the front that he puts on. He acts tough, but cannot handle himself when he gets in fights.
The supreme example of his immaturity is the fact that by the end of the story he learns nothing from is experiences. So is Holden Caulfield some kind of culture hero? He seems more like your average loser.
**I would like my writing to be read for organization and originality. Other than that, anything else you think of is up to you =).**
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Mi, your post on the novel reminded me of a psychoanalysis that a psychologist conducts on a patient. Your post was really interesting in how you deeply analyzed Holden's character in who he's trying to become as a young adult and who he's turning out to be. (Internal Conflict). Your 2nd, 3rd, and 4th paragraphs were extremely captivating to me. I agree with you in how many teens experience Holden's emotional journey. Great Job!
ReplyDeleteMia, I think that if you were to expand this post, you might focus on some of the underlying causes that might explain what you call Caulfield's immaturity. Is this merely a product of his adolescence, or does Salinger point to specific influences that have caused him to be the person he is?
ReplyDeleteMia, I think your post was organization and had originality.Your right that Holden acts tough, but cannot handle himself when he gets in fights. I agree with that. Keep up with the good work =]
ReplyDelete